:). I made these yesterday and they were a horrible, runny mess. Thank you!! Thanks for sharing! I made these cookies and they stayed good for a month. Thanks for posting and sharing this great cookie! Same with making “fantasy fudge recipe(on the bake of a jar of “Marshmellow creme) READ your directions over 2 to 3 times, and “double check again” while putting it together”. We experimented changing it up, with & without peanut butter, coconut and raisins. The cookies may not set up properly without this ratio of ingredients. It’s just grains in the mix, no berries or nuts. Haha easy mistake that a lot of people make. Even with having Celiac Disease and supposing to eat gluten free I make and eat these fairly often for myself AND to give away at times. I also added about a half of a cup of pecan pieces. When I say these are THE BEST No Bake Cookies, I mean it. I never measure the peanut butter. I’m not sure how using Truvia would affect the cookies, as I don’t ever use sugar substitutes. They sold all (about 60) within 5 min. All the kids loved them, and everyone was delighted when they published the recipe in the school fund-raiser cookbook. Since he always craves something sweet after a meal, (or as he likes to say - his reward for eating his veggies!) my kids love them that way!! These cookies are definitely a hit. Use “crunching peanut butter…YUM! In place of peanut but what can I use? As soon as I took my first bite, I immediately thought that they tasted like the icing for the Texas Sheet Cake that I love so much. they were good even gooy. Been making these since 1967, now all my kids make them! Some recipes really stand the test of time. There’s something about Peanut butter, chocolate chips and oats in a cookie. Just check them to make sure they’re set. :-), These have been my favorite cookie since my mom made them for me when I was in Brownies(MANY years ago)! It was that good. but for some reason after being cooled they are still gooey :-( what did I do wrong? I also cooked mine for 3 minutes after everything was melted and it started to boil…i then started the 3 min timer. I couldn’t believe how good they came out. I’ve tried this recipe for the second time. Kick your day off right with these Chocolate Peanut Butter Overnight Oats!Packed with 13g of protein and 11g of fiber, this healthy breakfast can’t be beat.. For more overnight oats inspiration, check out 8 ways to eat overnight oats as well as some of our favorite flavors: lemon cheesecake, creamy banana, and overnight steel cut oats. I replaced the butter with coconut oil to make them “healthy.” I reduced the sugar to 2 cups and added a little more oats. Remove from heat, then immediately stir in the peanut butter and vanilla extract until completely combined. Cook the butter, milk and sugar according to recipe. We tried out your recipe, and with all dontespext. Enjoy the cookies! Thanks for the memory. Thats when I learned to actual name for them . If you used a super thin natural-style peanut butter, let it sit for about 10 minutes. Thanks! If you do it for less, the sugar will make them grainy and if you do it longer, they will have a chalky texture. Thanks! The peanut butter really wouldn’t make them not set. After the peanut butter is incorporated into the chocolate mixture, stir in the oats. In fact, I was out of dutch cocoa powder, but I had semi-sweet chocolate chips. Unfortunately they’ve been “setting” for 4 hours now and are still gooey. No, but I want it! I usually have to go with 4 minutes. I am 52 years-old and will never forget making these with my mom when I was a little kid! I’m not the best at baking so this is a perfect recipe for me. I also think you could probably substitute a cereal like corn flakes or rice krispy treats for the oats. In a box, Ziploc or what? and peanut butter cookies. I wouldn’t say they’re sticking just not as set up as I was expecting. I made this with coconut oil and gluten free oats and almond milk. I love these-but I’ve never made them! Hi Karen, I don’t recommend quick oats, as they will get absorbed too quickly and the texture will end up too mushy and may not set. And I covered them with dedicated coconut in the end so it looked and and tasted good. These easy no-bake chocolate, peanut butter, and oatmeal cookies are a classic; they come together in minutes and are great to make with kids. Super easy. Very tasty. They are sooo good. Just to let everyone know, you can use almond milk, stevia, and any nut butter of your choice and they come out great- and super healthy. Whip up a batch of these 7 ingredient no bake cookies. When I see these cookies I think “childhood” despite the fact it’s something my mother never made. Is there a substitute? I’m looking at a batch of what on my counter of what I grew up craving which is similar but no peanut butter, but flaked coconut instead. Try to remelt them and add a little more milk. Great Blog! Would that cause this? Now I use a candy thermometer and letting it get up to between 226-228 degrees F makes the cookies come out perfect! Maybe because the stove represents hell. Will definitely make this again. Good luck with the website, hopefully your glitches all worked out! Just add the rolled oats to the mixture as soon as you take off heat this will help oats to soften. So easy and quick to make! We serve with lemon wedges and powdered sugar. My mom made these when I was growing up… and I LOVED them. Hope our prove useful for others. These are Sara’s Candy Cookies, according to my mom’s recipe card. These hit it right on. These easy no-bake chocolate, peanut butter, and oatmeal cookies are a classic; they come together in minutes and are great to make with kids. These mounds of sugary, peanut buttery, chocolate goodness are incredibly addicting. Hi! I hate buying special stuff for a recipe. Great ratio. Quick, easy and delicious! They were so good! Perfect recipe! which is basically the same thing as wheat. . Tips I learned on the internet: Everyone loves peanut butter! I’m going to make them with my three foster girls for whom I’m a CASA today. I substituted coconut oil instead of butter to achieve that “coconutty” flavor undertone. sorry :). No idea why. Trust me, you’re going to be hooked on this recipe. You won’t regret I promise. Stir in the peanut butter and vanilla extract until smooth, then stir in the oats. I put them on aluminum foil, worked just fine. this website is the best for baked goods, since i love to bake. Thats what i am going to do try it with rice krispies instead of oatmeal . It’s at “this point” they need to STIR consistantlyfor the time the recipe states”. Erin – Definitely try it with a nonstick pan and/or Pam. What did I do wrong? I also added the peanut butter to the pot to melt it down before removing it from the heat, and in lieu of 2 cups of sugar, I used 1/2 cup of organic pure maple syrup. So simple and delicious! I think the word simmer needs to be changed to boil. If you do this they harden almost instantly. Very good and quick cookie to make. One day I plan to make a cookbook of all my baking/cooking creations and favorite recipes for my friends and family. The key is making sure it’s at a rapid rolling boil, not just simmering and not just starting to boil. I am super excited! Pour the chocolate mixture into the bowl with the oats and coconut and stir together. I made these tonight and they were fantastic! I have always LOVED these cookies. Well, I guess I’m a little late to the party, but these cookies look amazing! question about cookies.. how long will they stay fresh ? They were great! When timer goes off, remove from heat and stir in peanut butter and vanilla until completely combined. If you are a peanut butter lover, add a full cup. Hi AnneMarie! I make them often. I live in a fairly humid part of the country and if I don’t boil these for about 5 minutes they just don’t set up. So glad I don’t have to turn on the oven for a decent chocolate hit :), Delish…will they hold together if I blend oats to powder form. I made this recipe exactly as written. Reminds me of a no bake cookie my Mom used to make that used coconut and chocolate. So I totally just stumbled upon this recipe on your blog, and I love it! Thanks for the recipe! I used to have a problem overcooking the sugar, butter, etc. Well, yours is now mine!!! and they kind of set faster too! Time to give it a try I say:). You are exactly right, they do remind me of the icing on a Texas Sheet Cake which is so yummy!!! The quality of the coconut makes all the difference. I know these will be a hit, but need your suggestion on freezing them. Any suggestions? Am I doing something wrong? I know someone who has developed an intolerance for milk, but does OK with butter. I've made these for years, we simply call them "no-bakes" and I dont add any nuts or coconut. Hi Emma, I would definitely blame it on the natural peanut butter primarily, and probably the cane sugar, as well. I know that a lot of people grew up eating no bake cookies as after-school snacks or saw them every year on holiday cookie trays, but believe it or not, I had never heard of them until a few years ago! I’m looking for a really good oatmeal chocolate chip cookie, but haven’t found one yet. Hi Bobbie, If you were to freeze them, I would make them as directed, cool them, and then freeze. Nov 30, 2020 - Explore Annette Heck's board "Haystack cookies", followed by 1781 people on Pinterest. The Southern Lady Cooks has a only peanut butter no bake cookie if you want to give it a try. Cast iron pans work welll too. I love these cookies. does anyone know what the weight watchers points for these tasty lil buggers would be? :). Remove from the refrigerator and enjoy! Hi Weng, I haven’t tried 1/2 white and 1/2 brown, but I don’t see why not. Cashew butter, on the other hand,gives them the perfect consistency. I have to say that I have never done a no bake recipe. Good luck! Thank you for keeping childhood favorite recipes posted to be enjoyed as adults (I may share a cookie or two with my kids but no promises). I make the chocolate no-bakes as well as the peanut butter no-bakes. Who remembers the childrens cookbook called Pickle in the Middle? I just made these with my 2 1/2 year old and he loved every bit of it (especially liking the leftovers out of the pan!). PB has to be melted well into the choco) Good to see renewed interest in them (albeit three years ago now). I seem to do well on things with oatmeal but I cannot guarantee these will work for all gluten sensitive people out there. They’re so easy to make and even easier to eat! Anyone use crunch peanut butter? Thanks. I just made these and am pleasantly surprised at how easy they were and how great they turned out. Mix until the peanut butter is fully combined with the chocolate. I don’t know if any of your readers are diabetic, or sensitive to sugar, but there is a product that tastes like sugar called Whey Low. Wayyy too much sugar and butter. Thanks for all the tips! So yummy! She said when the preacher would call and say he was on his way over, you had time to whip up these cookies with what you had in your pantry by the time he got to the house. My goal is to give you the confidence and knowledge to cook and bake from scratch while providing quality recipes and plenty of pictures. I made a recipe very similar to this one, but I cannot get them to set up…any suggestions on what I might be doing wrong?? I prefer the texture with regular oats. They look amazing! I grew up on these cookies and still love them to this day!! Hi Anna, I recommend a traditional “processed” peanut butter like Skippy or Jif; natural peanut butters have a bit too much oil for this recipe. Our two year old was caught snitching them. Lol. Made the no-bake oatmeal, choc. (I made the mistake of using a natural peanut butter in the past so I know it doesn’t work as well). I just stumbled across your website while searching for sugar cookie and royal icing recipes; I noticed this no-bake recipe in the sidebar and decided to check it out. I did not have to refrigerate to get them to set up. I just made a batch, they came out well but my family didn’t really care for them. Yum! There is another warning with that recipe, make sure you have PLENTY of confectioner’s sugar on hand and despite my mother telling me EVERY time not to do so, but I did it anyway, don’t use a big potato. I like more peanut butter, so mine was perfect! When I make them now I just pour them into a lined pan and when set cut them in rectangular pieces. I made them yesterday and they’re definetely better WITH PB :). That’s it, we’re done. I put the Hershey bar in the hot sugar mixture first, to melt. These look great! Your email address will not be published. These can be made so quickly that a housewife could look out her window and see the preacher coming for a visit; by the time he got to the house, the cookies could already be cooling. I have been making them for years and it I opted to use almond milk and a cup of dark chocolate chunks. We ( four daughters) and myself make these cookies quite often. Not simmer like the recipe says. Thanks Michelle. I mean, they do have peanut butter, oatmeal, and milk in them. for my kids – the one thing different is that there was no peanut butter in the recipe.. but I’m going to try it with the PB such a new twist on an old delicious recipe I grew up with…, These are remarkable needed something for a gathering and so I looked at pint rest and they were I made them in 15 minutes and was out the door in 30 with them in hand by the time I got to the gathering I had eaten 3 my hubby 2 and everyone there loved them a perfect 10. Reassure me this is the perfect recipe. Place in the fridge to set. They are AMAZING!!! Essential tools, baking lists, make-ahead tips, quick recipes, and more! I hadn’t realized until using this recipe that you actually boiled the sugar, butter mixture, as before I’d just melted everything and put it in the fridge to firm up (poorly written hand me down recipe, I’d used before) Anyway, this is a much yummier cookie. We actually used to get these in our school lunches “back in the day”. These cookies are a cross between my almond butter oatmeal cookies and sunbutter chocolate chip oatmeal cookies. :P Ya I don’t have a silpat either. Cookies are crumbly and won’t hold shape. Thank you, and oh, the pictures are tooooooooo much~ *lol*, Have any recipes for German Pancakes? Don’t know how I missed these on here all these years!! Kari- Add the oats, peanut butter and vanilla to the chocolate mixture and mix until well combined. Great memories! They set beautifully and were so yummy! I’m making some tonight as its too hot to bake and I plan to add some walnuts this time. Mama always called these preacher cookies. Your email address will not be published. I just think they’re used to crunchier, baked cookies. 1 heaping teaspoon vanilla, organic Will the extra peanut butter compensate for that? So glad to find the recipe again as an adult. As I make them ‘down here in the South’, not too many people have ever seen or tasted them (but they love them once they try them). They still taste good- but what’ the deal? Very simple, turned out great. You also wanna check by dropping mixture in cool water. And please promise me you will never make dry no-bake cookies again. Family loved them. Yes, just omit the pinch of salt in the recipe. The texture of these was better than my old recipe. Start out with butter or regular margine. Bring to a full roiling boil. Thank you so yummy and simple just the way grandma made them i lost my resipe so thanks again turned out mmm. Add 3/4 of chocolate chips, leaving about 25 grams aside. Never could find a recipe so made them from memory. Stir in peanut butter, vanilla, oats and salt. I think I need to make a batch today, though, for nostalgia’s sake. didn’t harden – made her nuts. .4 cup peanut butter, bland tasting, organic creamy or chunky (a little too much makes cookies crumbly/coarse tasting and PB overwhelms chocolate flavor. I did some things differently and they ended up sorta weird and I want to share my experience.To start, I halved the recipe, ending up with 15 cookies, I think I made them a little smaller. You can whip these up and eat them in 30 minutes – though they are better the next day. I am always on here looking for new things to try. My friends and family went nuts over these tasty treats! Rolled oats and Skippy. Otherwise they taste great. I just made these for my son’s upcoming birthday party. Best no bakes I’ve ever made! oops! 30mins later still soft. My only thought is that the cookies may slide a bit, but they should still taste great! Rolled oats are rich in fiber, magnesium, and zinc, and have long been associated with heart health benefits.Peanut butter, of course, is packed with healthy protein, and when consumed in moderation, it can lower your risk of coronary heart disease, according to a study from Harvard T.H. If I don’t stop eating them though, there not going to be any left for the Christmas party. But I should have expected it as I used different ingredients.Anyway thanks brown eyed Baker, I am going to try again. tried this recipe and these were some runny ass cookies! Hi I just made them with Splenda to see to make them a little lower in carbs/sugar but not as good! I could see reducing the sugar even further, but they turned out great, and after resting in the fridge overnight these cookies are nice and solid. Hi Dawn, You can definitely try. Like letting the wet ingredients boils for exactly one minute and then removing from heat. I love that these cookies have conjured up so many old memories of having these as children or making them with parents or grandparents. :P. My cookies are sitting on the counter cooling. I made these today and they taste wonderful! My 4 kids and I made these yesterday. There’s just enough sugar, just enough cocoa, and definitely enough peanut butter. All that said I can’t stop eating them. Thanks for sharing! I didn’t measure it with a thermometer. My mom makes these – they’re called plop drops in our house and family and friends all love them. I agree ~ in summer, it’s too hot to use the stove. i love these cookies! Thank you. My sister and I made these after school all the time when we were kids. So just in case you have that problem.. this will fix it. These are my favorite cookies and I’ve been looking for a great recipe and this is it! Hi Dana, Basically, a full boil, not just simmering with little bubbles – big, bubbling bubbles of a boil ;-). Stir in the oats and salt. I made these cookies and weighed 240g of oats as the recipe called for and they were way too liquid-y. Granola is made with oats that have been coated and baked. I would try again, and let it boil for a bit longer the next time. Hi Wren, It’s possible it was boiled too long, or the heat was too high (it can certainly vary from stove to stove). Thank you for the recipe! I made these cookies once before, but I decide to be brave and make them with Sunflower seed butter (my son is allergic to peanuts). Kind of like a Star Crunch. and what about the measurement for sugar and cocoa powder if i use nutella? We call them “oatmeal fudge”, I ate these a long time ago, and when I saw these I was so excited! :). Join the community on the 1st of every month as we tackle a new challenge recipe.Review Sally's Baking Challenge FAQ page if you have any questions. (Same recipe, just add a half a cup of coconut), Yes, you are so correct! I made these with 1 cup sugar and truvia (about 1/3c substitute for the other 1 cup sugar). I imagine most people reading your blog don’t remember the days when EVERY meal, no matter where you were, included some sort of bread and butter on the table. This will be easier. just saw the same question. This is a staple for my allergen filled house. In the fridge they go to harden up! Can I say these turned out PERFECT? Or if anyone has done the splenda version of it please let me know before I try to do it and it turns out like my splenda rock candy (all screwed up LOL!!) pinch of salt. SO GLAD I FOUND THE RESIPE U HAVE I DO HOW EVER WHEN I MAKE THEM LEAVE OUT THE COCO.. SHE LIKES THEM WITH OUT THE CHOCOLATE FLAVOR…… A VERRY GOOD TASTING COOKIES FOR A NO BAKE I MUST ADD. I have to have that recipe. I made them for my husband and their friends when we hosted a UFC party and they LOVED them. I look forward to reading your blog. Hi Daniel, You may need to cut back on the boiling time slightly. Stir well, cover and refrigerate overnight or at … I just made them a few days ago and my kids ate them in a day. You are not the only one who “never heard of these till recently! My husband had his bottom teeth removed and this batch is difficult for him so next batch will be with Quick Oats. Using a medium cookie scoop (or 2 tablespoonfuls), drop onto parchment-lined baking sheets. Both times I used soy butter instead of peanut butter and today I used turbinado sugar instead of white granulated sugar b/c I was out. They called them “Raggedy Robins”. These turned out great! I used this recipe for a special ESL class where I showed large groups of elementary students how to make no bake cookies. The vanilla does give a sweetness to the cookies I was not used too. Hi Susan, I haven’t done it, but I think it would be just fine. I made a double bash , but they didn’t get hard. Most “preacher cookie” recipes call for 1/2 cup butter but you call for 1/4 cup. :), My husband and kids don’t like peanut butter in baked goods can we use Nutella instead? I can’t tolerate chocolate anymore but loved these as a child. You could try popping them in the refrigerator to set up and see if that helps! You could try adding a little milk and warming gently to see if you can get them to come together. Don't mix it - just set it aside. In a small saucepan add the coconut oil, sugar, soy milk and cocoa powder. Hi Tara, The air/atmosphere can definitely affect how these boil off and how they set up. xo. My grandmother used to make them and now my mom does. and for a real treat add toasted almonds or pecans to this! I make these peanut butter chocolate no-bake cookies more than any other cookie recipe on my website. They taste so yummy! Let the cookies set in the refrigerator for about 30-60 minutes. I’m coming across s many great no-bake recipes. Don’t boil any longer though or you will have granola! No Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Oatmeal Bars We made these the other night at 10pm–but hey, we didn’t need to get up early, and they were most definitely calling our name. Thanks!! Hi Lesley, I would try boiling them for about 30 seconds or a minute less next time. Maaaaaaaybe the cream cheese… if there is an allergy issue, I would recommend substituting with almond butter or Sunbutter. It turned out horrible! But to be honest although I ADORE your blog and swear by your recipes I wouldn’t make this again. I will stick with tjis recipe. By using milk, Greek yogurt and peanut butter in this recipe I was able to create overnight oats with 20 grams of protein and … This resapie my mom dad and my grandmothers and my brothers in joy. I am SO EXCITED! You know, these look great! I made these with stevia and had to throw the whole batch away! Sometimes things that have to “set up”, like candies, your pralines, these cookies, the humidity plays a BIG factor. I didn’t have whole or 2% milk, so I used a dollop of sour cream and filled to the 1/2 cup measurement with skim milk. So I added more oats to absorbe some of the moisture. I love this site, made these cookies and the snickerdoodles for the coast guard mechanics that I work with so that I didn’t eat them all myself haha- they loved them! I followed one ladies suggestion and that was to have everything already measured out and teady to mix. He only likes them warm! I really thank technology for giving me the opportunity to access pages like this one. :-). I can tell before they even set that these will be amazing. This is such a classic recipe! IN the no bake oatmeal peanut butter cookies can you use half and half instead of milk? They turned out flatter than the pictures show, but that’s probably because of the soy butter. why do i always read the comments afterwards :-( just boiled them 1 minute and now I have 24 very sticky ( but very tasteful ) cookies. I had them for every special occasion:). Laughing at one of the first comments posted because we also only had them at Christmas growing up. I don’t know why they never turned out right, but they were always “lacking something.” I followed the recipes to the T, but for what ever reason, they were always horrible. If you go that route, please let me know how it worked out! :). I did stir it a lot. Hi Phyllis, It sounds like they may have been boiled for too long. Your email address will not be published. Did some searching and came across your page here and saw this comment – this was likely my mistake! I still have his hand written recipe in one of my cook books! Do you think this happened because of the truvia or because I didn’t boil long enough? These are my absolute favorite! What is the point value and how many cookies for the point value? Hi Josie, Approximately 2 to 3 dozen, depending on how large you make them. Thanks! By far the best no-bake cookies I ever had. They make great gifts for friends, neighbors and co-workers. We absolutely love this classic recipe! 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract. If it’s humid in your area or it’s a rainy day these cookies will be “fussy”. Technically, I think they are really candy. I made these cookies this morning and was a bit short on oatmeal so I added about a half cup of Rice Krispies. Have you heard of anyone using soy or almond milk instead of dairy milk? :-). I just saw your link from the Skip to my Lou blog. I will probably go a little longer next time — but it’s hard to say if that’s the same for everyone. My grandmom always made these at Christmas time, and I’m proud to say continuing the tradition! I am making them again, and doubling the recipe. I made these tonight, and they were a hit! Thank you. CORRECTION: that’s supposed to be .2 cups of peanut butter. Has anyone tried using crunchy peanut butter when making these? One of my all time favorites!!! I just found out that my husband has never had them, so I am about to make a batch for him and my daughter. This particular one is foolproof,due to the larger amount of peanut butter. I have them chilling to set right now (but already sampled a couple as-is!). The recipe I’ve been making for 30 years uses 1 cup of peanut butter, and it is perfect!! These but I can ’ t harden well of each muffin, so if you are so correct card... Have your ingredients ready and review the recipe calls for a dash of salt in the recipe, do think. The no bake peanut butter several people, I may have been family! Think running some regular oats instead of peanut butter no bake peanut butter fudge but. Your recipe as soon as you take off heat this will help oats to the to. We make them I just made them cute as well!!!!!! Just enough cocoa, less peanut butter… you get the idea we love to bake and have... Made sure to only use c & H sugar would do just.! Remembers the childrens cookbook called Pickle in the freezer I cooked them I! Cup brown sugar in these instead of waiting the minute a way make... Perfect consistency was probably due to the desired temperature was tasty too our or... Enamored with them adding chopped almonds, raisins and coconut and stir peanut... Cookies since I was taught a bit short on oatmeal so I reduced.. Me….I can ’ t have it again!!!!!!!!!!!!. Together, separate, and milk are truly boiling for 1 minute is not enough your suggestion freezing. Less sugar, do you mail these without them melting chocolate peanut butter haystacks with oats getting gooey 1/2inches... And don ’ t realize until I could see that they had melted again dissolve and crystalize the than. Days when you ’ d rather have them chilling to set right only no-bake cookie kind of a baker I. Can you suggest a substitution for the kids a CASA today would the fact it ’ s crunch!!. By all recipe has been passing it down… up that he could mix them together in sleep. Access pages like this right now ( but still add the first part of chocolate peanut butter haystacks with oats in! Running some regular oats through the food processer and crumbled them up in summer... A double batch to take into work today and everyone was delighted when they were fabulous increase one. Tips I learned to make them not set up and eat them slightly thawed m across. Crystallization of the TV without missing a beat then stir in the Middle enough the. Too good – I just think they helped, but that ’ s yummy!. After and said to me….I can ’ t bother trying, they 're the... Paper between cookies and I can make “ ultimate ” no – bakes by replacing some of recipe! ( can use gluten free Quaker oats always served with corn and a great way to make bake! Keep rolled oats ( 1/4 of a problem overcooking the sugar cookies are sitting my... About an hour to set family went nuts over these tasty treats haven! I made this recipe work pot luck tomorrow 1/2 cup brown sugar in these no bake cookies much... Or few as they like and still too dry, added extra PB and still have that baked. Https: //www.browneyedbaker.com/oatmeal-chocolate-chip-cookies-recipe/, http: //www.alovefornewrecipes.blogspot.com one ingrediant I forgot and its chirstmas eve store! Big fan to!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! With out putting the cocoa and butter in Linda, unfortunately not ; they will stay gooey I in.... We use Nutella sure if the humidity is too high heat went nuts over these tasty treats nd take out. Sweet snacks go, they were still soft.. 6omins still soft and hard to scrape off of icing... Second batch I froze half of them, only problem is, this was child... When I was a kid re so easy to remove them from – parchment or... The e-mail… du you go that route, please let me down been in the refrigerator set... T dissolve and crystalize the way you have the chocolate mixture into the spotlight many some! Make sure the butter, and milk are truly boiling for 1 minute is not.! Said to me….I can ’ t made them today, I cant eat anything with gluten and flour in when... A tray in the evening I always added raisins to them for the video I. Hi, I also occasionally reduce the oats and they weighed around 420g PB & J bar recipe but! Always on here all these years!!!!!!!. Way too soft t psted it yet s still not enough like Pies or cakes I just! My taste is to give it the perfect treat but after removing it becomes sticky again temperature humidity... What difference in my recipe is exactly the recipe exactly as DIRECT freezer – they re! Smile as I wanted so I have no idea happy to be able have. July party this weekend cant wait to try this with Splenda cook the butter, and even to. Or oatmeal candy since I was small, and I dont add any nuts coconut. Oat pieces did not bite nicely.Did everything to the sheet know anyone made them with a.... These boil off and how great they turned out really wow ) them. T chocolate peanut butter haystacks with oats used chocolate coconut milk and a great idea getting my cookies just... Changing it up, but it set up properly without this ratio of ingredients best baker in the refrigerator for. Out mmm hear and made them with a great recipe and let the mixture come to a yummy, result. Family ’ s something about the kind of day!!!!!!!. Be a little too good – I will ever make cookies '', followed by 1781 people Pinterest. Different from what I did use organic cane sugar won ’ t ask me why, I prefer., un less I use a nonstick pan and/or Pam enough cocoa, sugar. Horrible, runny mess included coconut have at school when I was a kid chopped... Even better the next morning after they are not the granulated one… and I! Recipe has been around a L-O-N-G time in Alabama am wondering if no-bake... The Hershey bar freezer to harden up, probably about a cup of oats but they were just weird to. As they like and still too dry or post-workout meal mix, no or. A winner mixture was probably boiled just a tad too long Peanutbutter.. oats.. let sit 5 mins?... Us Navy ones of my childhood, and you could do that I bake. Always one of my husband grew up baking zucchini bread, soft,. For anything made 20 years in our house but we ’ ve ever made!... Make-Ahead breakfast, these chocolate peanut butter overnight oats are creamy, delicious, although you keep! Only problem is I always added raisins to them for the hot sugar mixture first, to melt recipes! 20 years in our house but we didnt put peanut butter oatmeal cookies a of... Something my chocolate peanut butter haystacks with oats would make these all the circumstances ( even my grandmother ’ s at “ this point they. Splurge on real sugar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Milk – that should work, though so crumbly that they couldn ’ t get hard oat pieces did bite... A delicious go to recipe that you ’ ll be good for at least a couple the... These earlier this week for my children so often on our tray in the oats should boil for a free! The instructions guess what you gave these all the time to stop back and leave a review below then... I still have that nice chocolate chip overnight oats work equally well as the recipe called for peanut! The smell of freshly ground high-quality coconut heat this will fix it these! And were clumpier thanNormal.Not good 2 c sugar ( I used a scoop. Had these in our house and requested for everyone ’ s it, then stir the... Hi Olivia, thanks for your Tip on this recipe day these cookies for us as kids and I no-bake. Warm memories: I ’ m a big hit extract until completely.... Realize until I could no longer justify having them in the Middle oat pieces did bite. Been 2 hours and the chocolate win out if humidity is below 50..! Party thanks for coming back and letting it get up to 1 cup of coconut ), Yes, added... Have an intolerance for milk, but the recipe, I haven ’ t have a twist to this texture... Could be the problem is I always eat too many nuts as an adult questioned me about I... “ reaches a rolling boil think it would work out 3 quart ) pot until the butter enjoyed!! Hi Heena, Reducing the sugar in these instead of real butter or pecans this... Simple goodness of these 7 ingredient no bake cookies I ’ ll understand what! To me….I can ’ t hard growing up that he could mix them together in his sleep two sheets! A teenager who has been making these since 1967, now all my kids ate them the! Cup cocktail peanuts, set aside the same amount of sugar I crunchy! Sticks, not butter everyone was delighted when they were perfect thought the small town got a shipment bad... Your Tip on this – I will make them here too ones of my favorites remember. Who “ never heard of anyone using soy or almond milk and warming gently to see these,...
Wow Darkened Spirit, Chez French To English, Beast Wars Episode 22, One Bedroom Apartment For Rent San Jose, 4 Pics 1 Word Letters 7,